The tech giant, NVIDIA, once again stirred the financial waters when it released its second-quarter earnings report on August 28. Anticipated for months, its report managed to exceed Wall Street's predictions and marked a staggering growth trend, with revenues surpassing $30 billion and profits tripling. However, the euphoria was short-lived as, surprisingly, the company’s stock plummeted nearly 7% in after-hours trading, resulting in a market capitalization evaporating by approximately $200 billion. This stark contrast between anticipated and actual market movements underscores a profound disconnect between optimistic projections and the guarded reality of stock prices.

NVIDIA's founder and CEO, Jensen Huang, attempted to downplay the overwhelming expectations placed on his company, stating, “We can only focus on doing our work. Everyone is racing towards the future, and our responsibility is to help the world achieve it.” Huang's resolute statements emphasize his commitment to guiding NVIDIA into a pivotal role in the rapidly evolving AI landscape. While the company has indeed successfully embraced accelerated computing, enabling users to reap "instant returns" on their investments in NVIDIA chips, the market's reaction suggests that the investors' optimistic sentiments became overly inflated.

Advertisement

To understand the aftermath of the earnings report, one must delve deeper into NVIDIA’s stock performance trends. In a remarkable resurgence that began at the end of 2022, NVIDIA’s stock soared nearly ninefold, pushing its market cap past the $3 trillion mark. As reported by Bespoke Investment Group, NVIDIA’s earnings report has ascended into the realm of the "most crucial financial news stories in the world." The company has undoubtedly positioned itself prominently within the tech sector, with its stock responsible for over a quarter of the S&P 500's growth this year. Nevertheless, following a historic peak in June, NVIDIA has witnessed a reduction in its market cap by nearly 30% over the past two months.

Analysts have suggested that the current lofty market rates for NVIDIA are predicated on "perfect" performance. Bernstein analyst Stacy Rasgon articulated this perspective, noting that for stock prices to see another upward trend, NVIDIA's performance guidance would need to significantly surpass existing expectations. Yet, despite the volatile nature of the stock market, Rasgon still advocates for purchasing NVIDIA shares, positing that there is no clear indication of diminishing demand for NVIDIA GPU technologies. He remarked, “GPUs remain the core infrastructure for developing and running AI models. Market demand continues to be robust.”

JJ Kinahan, president of the online trading platform Tastytrade, offered a concise sentiment observing, “The earnings beat expectations, but people had too high of an expectation.” He added that he remained uncertain if NVIDIA could deliver sufficiently impressive numbers that would please its investors. Undoubtedly, the intense demand for AI chips has fueled NVIDIA's consistent outperformance in quarterly earnings; nonetheless, the most recent financial report revealed a decline in gross profit margin from 78.4% in the prior quarter to 75.1%, albeit still surpassing the 70.1% recorded in the same period last year. Furthermore, forecasted gross margins are projected to maintain around 70% throughout the year—below the anticipated 76.4% by analysts.

In an interview with a financial news outlet, DBS Bank's Chief Investment Strategist, Heng Zhi-jian, remarked on the market's reaction to NVIDIA's financial disclosures. He noted that many investors seemed to believe NVIDIA’s stock price had already accounted for the earnings report and, thus, even exceeding expectations failed to impress. Additionally, he highlighted that in contrast to last quarter’s staggering 628% profit increase, there has been a notable slow-down prompting profit-taking strategies among investors.

Concerns have also arisen regarding the timeline of NVIDIA’s next-generation AI chip, Blackwell, which some investors fear might be delayed and thus impact future profit growth. Nonetheless, NVIDIA has reassured stakeholders that the Blackwell chips are scheduled for shipment in the fourth quarter of this year while also predicting revenue in the “multibillion-dollar” range for 2023.

I am convinced that NVIDIA’s stock does not bear a significant premium, and there’s no evidence that market demand for its chips has diminished,” stated Heng, affirming the company’s undeniable competitive edge. “Competitors cannot offer equivalent performance alternatives in the immediate term.”

Another pressing concern for investors pertains to the sustainability of large customers' investments in AI infrastructure. During the earnings call, analysts inundated NVIDIA's executives with inquiries concerning whether these customer investments yield profitability. In response, NVIDIA reiterated that investing in its AI chips guarantees "immediate returns," claiming that for every dollar invested in NVIDIA chips by cloud service providers, a return of $5 could be expected over four years.

Highlighting the strategic importance of AI within corporate frameworks, Huang amplified the conversation surrounding generative AI, asserting that major companies, including Meta, have harnessed NVIDIA’s chips to construct cost-effective recommendation systems to enhance profitability.

Huang emphasized that investing in AI infrastructure currently stands as one of the most profitable infrastructure investment strategies available. The backdrop to this assertion is a paradigm shift in computing that transitions from generic computing to accelerated computing methods. He underscored the role of NVIDIA chips that empower not only chatbot applications but also advertising systems, search engines, robotics, and underlying algorithms of social media recommendations.

"Investing in traditional CPU infrastructures has become inefficient. The advantages of AI chips stem from their cost-effective data processing, leveraging systems such as algorithmic recommendations to drive savings," Huang stated confidently. He further noted that all created infrastructures would be rented, as many companies are ceaselessly developing generative AI. “Your capacity would be instantly rented out—return on investment is exceedingly good,” he remarked.

The recent bull market in US equities has largely been propelled by technology giants making robust investments in AI. Early announcements indicated that Meta expects annual capital expenditures to fall within the range of $37 billion to $40 billion, increasing the lower limit by $2 billion from the previous quarter's guidelines. Microsoft similarly forecasted that its capital expenditures for fiscal 2025 would exceed the $56 billion outlay of 2024, while Google projected its quarterly capital expenditure would “match or exceed” the $12 billion mark.

However, some analysts assert that one of the factors contributing to NVIDIA's stock's heightened volatility is its heavy reliance on a few large clients—primarily cloud service providers—for substantial revenue streams. With the current earnings cycle provoking investor reticence toward tech stocks that can't substantiate lofty valuations, confidence in the AI-driven stock rally has faltered. Executives from both Google and Meta have conceded that they might have overspent on AI infrastructure, raising apprehensions among investors regarding whether these heavyweight AI players' already staggering expenditure could swell further in the heated race for dominance in the burgeoning AI technology sphere. Following its earnings announcement last month, stocks of Microsoft and Google have trended downwards, although these tech behemoths assert, “The risks of underinvestment are far too great, thus they must remain proactive.”

Gartner analyst Sheng Linghai expressed skepticism over the previously optimistic market demand for AI chips, suggesting that actual demand may not meet inflated expectations. "Market anticipations are typically overly optimistic, with substantial demand unlikely to remain consistent. There exists a distinct gap between extensive investment in AI and the anticipated returns," he mentioned.

During the earnings call, Huang reiterated that demand for NVIDIA’s current-generation AI chip, Hopper, remains “robust,” while projections for the next-generation Blackwell suggest demand will “greatly outstrip supply.” He concluded with an optimistic view, stating, “We are witnessing an escalation in the momentum of generative AI,” forecasting a “massive” growth surge in the company’s data center revenues for the following year.

However, whether NVIDIA’s confidence will continue to invigorate the capital markets in the long run remains a narrative still unfolding.